UPDATE: Nuclear Law Research Guide
By Linda Tashbook
Linda Tashbook is the Foreign International Comparative Law Librarian at the University Of Pittsburgh School Of Law's Barco Law Library, a Fulbright Senior Specialist, and an attorney in private practice. Prior to becoming the foreign and international librarian, she was the Barco Law Library's Electronic Services Librarian. Before law school, she worked as a public librarian. Her Juris Doctor and Master of Library Science degrees are from the University of Pittsburgh.
Published January 2013
Table of Contents
3.1. Information Sharing
6. Case Reports
An atom is the smallest unit of any element. The core of an atom is its nucleus, which is a combination of particles called protons and neutrons. Protons are positively charged particles and neutrons are neutral. Spinning around the outside of the nucleus are electrons; electrons are very small negatively charged particles. The particular combination of protons, neutrons, and electrons in the atoms of an element provide the element’s identity.
Two elements, plutonium and uranium, have variations (isotopes) which, when hit with an extra neutron that moves slowly, will split-- sending their neutrons crashing into other atoms causing those to split. All of this action, called fission, generates energy. Since it happens in the nucleus, the energy is called nuclear energy.
This fast chain reaction of spare neutrons from broken atoms hitting and breaking other atoms can be controlled by the addition of certain other elements or else it can be allowed to continue until so much energy builds-up that it causes an explosion. In other words, the process that generates safe nuclear energy is the same process that generates dangerous nuclear weapons.
Nuclear law regulates the possession, transportation, storage, and distribution of the plutonium and uranium isotopes that are prone to nuclear fission and it also regulates the ways fission has to be controlled. All of the following types of resources contain useful information about the existence, meaning, application, or enforcement of international nuclear law.
When researchers need a fundamental factual understanding about nuclear energy or nuclear weapons, such as definitions, abbreviations, or basic statistics, consult the following authoritative sources:
· Country Resources (Arms Control Association): This is a
country-by-country roster of nuclear treaty participation, weapons practices,
proliferation record, and other arms control activities.
There are numerous agencies responsible for the layers of communication, regulation, and enforcement associated with nuclear resources. Note that this list identifies IGO’s working on official information sharing, safety and security. It does not include the many NGO advocacy and education organizations that may have information of interest to legal researchers, but which are not directly involved in making or enforcing international law.
· Committee on Nuclear Regulatory Activities (OECD). Senior representatives from national nuclear regulatory offices “exchange information, review developments, and review current practices and operating experiences.” Resources include policy papers and research reports re operating nuclear facilities.
· European Atomic Energy Community. Known as EURATOM, this body “helps to pool knowledge, infrastructure, and funding of nuclear energy.” Resources include EU commission documents and links to all relevant EU laws, evaluations, studies, and standards.
· “The Global Nuclear Safety and Security Network (GNSSN) is a portal to “existing networks and information resources i.e. internationally accessible information and data sources, whether open or password protected that critical knowledge” established so that “experience, and lessons learned about nuclear safety and security are exchanged as broadly as they need to be.”
· Online Information Resource for Radioactive Waste Management (NEWMDB). Browse or search through reports and profiles about each IAEA Member State’s disposal program in this extensive and accessible compilation that aims not only to disseminate current information, but also to serve as the international memory for international standards and national practices regarding nuclear waste.
When nuclear science is used in medicine, energy generation, and manufacturing, safety standards and regulations seek to assure that all supplies are accounted for and that accidents do not happen.
· Asian Nuclear Safety Network. “Pools, analyzes and shares nuclear safety information, existing and new knowledge and practical experience among Asian countries… facilitates sustainable regional cooperation and creates human networks and cyber communities among the specialists of those countries.”
· Committee on the Safety of Nuclear Installations (OECD). Assists OECD member countries “in maintaining and further developing the scientific and technical knowledge base required to assess the safety of nuclear reactors and fuel cycle facilities.” Resources include much technical instruction.
· European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group (EU). Comprised of senior nuclear officials in the EU member states, this group works to assure safe nuclear installations, safe management of spent fuel, and safe decommissioning of nuclear installations. Resources include internal documents about the group’s work and also some good clear factual explanations about nuclear safety and radioactive waste disposal.
· International Atomic Energy Association (UN): Safety Standards Page—“The Global Nuclear Safety and Security Framework (GNSSF) is a basic conceptual structure and a set of guiding principles for achieving and maintaining a high level of safety and security at nuclear facilities and activities around the world.” (IAEA)
· International Commission on Radiological Protection. “Since 1928, ICRP has developed, maintained, and elaborated the International System of Radiological Protection used world-wide as the common basis for radiological protection standards, legislation, guidelines, programs, and practice.” Resources include hundreds of reports on radiation in medical settings, airplanes, commercial products, etc… Though not involved with law development or legal enforcement, the ICRP would be a good source for trial facts and expert witnesses.
· Nuclear Energy Agency (OECD) “assist[s] its member countries in maintaining and further developing, through international co-operation, the scientific, technological and legal bases required for the safe, environmentally friendly and economical use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes.” Resources include country reports and an ongoing series of policy papers specifically on the topic of nuclear regulation.
· World Association of Nuclear Operators. This organization “assesses, benchmarks, and improves” nuclear operations by publishing best practices, performance indicators, and various other safety-related industry publications.
International security measures prepare governments to handle nuclear accidents and intentional nuclear destruction.
· Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty Organization. Really a preparatory commission, readying for the day when the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty goes into effect, this organization works to prevent countries from testing prospective or actual nuclear weapons. Resources include explanations of the different types of nuclear weapons tests, descriptions of countries’ testing programs, and resources about the verification regime used to ascertain when and where nuclear explosions occur.
· International Atomic Energy Association—Nuclear Security. The IAEA serves to “review the general status of measures that protect against nuclear terrorism and identify ways to improve a broad spectrum of nuclear security activities.” Resources include security guidelines, fact sheets, periodicals, and training materials.
· Nuclear and Radiological Terrorism—Project Geiger (Interpol). Project Geiger maintains a database about illegal trafficking in nuclear and radiological materials. Resources include a monthly news journal, fact sheets, and authoritative reports about trafficking activities, but these publications are only available through Interpol’s National Central Bureaus.
· United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs. The UNODA “fosters disarmament measures through dialogue, transparency and confidence-building on military matters, and encourages regional disarmament efforts.” Resources include occasional papers, studies, several databases (including the resolutions and decisions database and the database of military expenditures), the Disarmament Yearbook, materials for educators, and a forthcoming repository of information provided by nuclear weapon states.
· UN Security Council 1540 Committee. Security Council Resolution 1540, from the year 2004, “imposes binding obligations on all States to establish domestic controls to prevent the proliferation of nuclear, chemical and biological weapons, and their means of delivery, including by establishing appropriate controls over related materials. It also encourages enhanced international cooperation on such efforts, in accord with and promoting universal adherence to existing international non proliferation treaties.” Resources include the original and related resolutions, a database of national laws demonstrating compliance with the resolution, and reports on implementation.
· Zangger Committee. This group of national representatives, “formed following the coming into force of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), to serve as the ‘faithful interpreter’ of its Article III, paragraph 2, to harmonize the interpretation of nuclear export control policies for NPT Parties.” Resources include committee meeting documents and UN documents about exports of nuclear materials and goods having nuclear potential.
· Missile Control Technology Regime. Committed to maintaining “vigilance over the transfer of missile equipment, material, and related technologies usable for systems capable of delivering WMD,” the MCTR primarily coordinates national export controls by which countries prevent missile components from being sold for use in weapons of mass destruction.
This treaty listing includes some guidance documents, such as codes of conduct, which are not strictly treaties because they arise more from the work of international organizations than from collective government negotiation. However, because of their informational role in standardizing expectations and advising regulatory development, these documents will be useful to researchers alongside treaties.
Although the U.S. dropped the first atomic bomb in 1945, it was not until 1963 that the first nuclear weapons treaty, The Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, was enacted. Read about the history of treaties on nuclear issues here.
Master Nuclear Treaty Lists are available from:
· Agreement Between the Republic of Argentina, the Federative Republic of Brazil, the Brazilian-Argentine Agency for Accounting and Control of Nuclear Materials and the IAEA for the Application of Safeguards
4.3. Treaties about Waste Management
4.4. Treaties about Nuclear Weapons
· Convention on Third Party Liability in the Field of Nuclear Energy (includes 1964 & 1982 Protocols)
Sites that can lead researchers to nuclear agencies and policies:
· Handbook on Nuclear Law (IAEA)—Volume I informs national legislatures of the domestic legal requirements set forth in international agreements. Volume II presents narrative summaries, model provisions, and other practical information to help national governments compose and implement nuclear legislation.
Examples of National Law:
· Keep an eye on the Global Legal Monitor for emerging nuclear law developments around the world.
· Nuclear Legislation (Browse by year and click on “find” for “nuclear.”)
See Legifrance for legislation. Use search term: “nucleaire”.
The International Atomic Energy Agency is responsible for monitoring national compliance with international nuclear agreements. When that agency has reason to believe that a country is violating international agreements, it informs the UN Security Council, which can issue resolutions, statements, and sanctions. Here, for example, are Resolutions and Statements relevant to nuclear issues in Iran. These efforts typically rally national governments to cease certain aspects of trade with the non-compliant country or to freeze assets, etc… National governments themselves, individually or collectively, can seek advice or action from the International Court of Justice. Victims harmed by inadequate or failed nuclear safeguards can sue in domestic court or bring claims in human rights tribunals. Most of the regional human rights tribunals have not dealt with nuclear issues, but there have been some nuclear cases in the European Court of Human Rights.
Here are some of the most well known international nuclear cases:
· Marshall Islands Nuclear Claims Tribunal (Personal injury claims by residents of the Marshall Islands who suffer harm resulting from U.S. nuclear testing)
International nuclear energy law books might be classed in various places within the US Library of Congress’s K3600-3990 call number range, but nuclear energy regulation specifically falls in K3986-K3990.
· Nuclear Law: The Law Applying to Nuclear Installations and Radioactive Substances in its Historic Context by Stephen Tromans
· The Oceans in the Nuclear Age: Legacies and Risks by Edited by David Caron and Harry N. Scheiber
· International Comparison of Nuclear Power Plant Staffing Regulations and Practice 1980-1990
· Edited by B. Melber, et al.
· Nuclear Energy Law After Chernobyl Edited by Peter Cameron, et al.
· Updating International Nuclear Law Edited by Heinz Stockinger, et al.
Nuclear Weapons Law is amidst other use of force materials in the US Library of Congress’s KZ 5600’s, and 6300’s-6400’s.
· Interpreting the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty by Daniel Joyner
· Nuclear Weapons, Justice and the Law by Elli Louka
· ASEAN, the Southeast Asia Nuclear-Weapon-Free Zone and the Challenge of Denuclearisation in Southeast Asia : Problems and Prospects by Bilveer Singh
· The use of nuclear weapons and the protection of the environment during international armed conflict by Erik Vincent Koppe
· Nuclear Weapons and Contemporary International Law by Nagendra Singh and Edward McWhinney